Thursday, February 19, 2015
I am currently in the process of reading my second independent reading book, Picnic at Hanging Rock. It’s a novel of mystery and suspense from the Australian author, Joan Lindsay. The setting is a girls’ boarding school in Australia in the year 1900. On a picnic to the nearby massive rock formation, Hanging Rock, three girls and a supervisor vanish without a trace. The rest of the novel follows the ensuing investigation, revealing shocking human truths along the way. Picnic at Hanging Rock is a novel of questions, not answers. The book is full of mystery, but never once do we ever get the sense that Lindsay feels obligated to really attempt to solve the mystery. That’s not the point. The book is not a whodunit. While revelations are come to about the girls (I won’t spoil anything) the rock at the center of the entire mystery remains shrouded in mystery. With no satisfying literal conclusion, one must search for a deeper meaning in the text. And believe me when I say that there is no shortage of meaning to be found in these pages. What I personally got out of the story was a striking commentary on the social stigma around female emotions and sexuality and the repression of such “uncomfortable” ideas. The rock is freedom from repression. When the girls first begin to explore the slopes of the rock and shed their shoes and stockings, they shed any bonds that the school, i.e. the order and structure of everyday society, has over them. When the girls disappear, they leave behind a younger girl, Sara, who wasn’t allowed on the picnic. Sara has an infatuation with Miranda, the most beautiful and mysterious of the vanished girls, which Miranda may or may not share. Whether it is simply a sisterly bond or something more scandalous remains unclear, but either way, I feel like it holds great meaning. I’m not exactly sure what. Overall, Lindsay is master of creating a huge amount of depth for her characters and ideas. The book is so rich, we feel as though there is so much about these character’s lives that goes unexplored, as if we are just reading the tip of the iceberg. Despite this feeling, never once do we truly desire to know more than what Lindsay presents us with. Any more would overcomplicate things. Reading the text as it is, we already feel voyeuristic, as if we are witnessing something forbidden and secret. And yet Lindsay relishes that feeling, basks in it, and we can’t look away. It’s too haunting. With beautifully crafted sentences and flowing prose, the novel is truly deserving of its status as a classic. A film based off Joan Lindsay’s novel was made during the 1970s brilliantly directed by Peter Weir. With a haunting soundtrack and gorgeous colors and cinematography, not to mention superb acting and direction, I would also highly recommend checking that out. It is just as good as the book, if not slightly better.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
This book sounds like something that I'd like to read. It's interesting how the author starts the book by making a few characters turn up missing, yet they do not focus on where they are. I'm guessing the story is more about the characters who remain and their depth. I'm writing a short story that has the same idea. The whereabouts of the missing are more the focus of the characters in the story than the readers. Did you wonder more about the missing characters and where they were, or did you just ponder about the characters who were available during the story? Since this story seems so interesting, I'm glad that there's a movie. Even though they don't tend to be better than the books, it's cool to see a story brought to life by a big screen. Did you watch the movie first or did you read the book first? This definitely has an effect on how the reader views the story.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI wanna know how Joan Lindsay has made the characters so drawn out to you. Is it simply because she focuses the story away from solving the mystery, and more into the heavy details of the case? Also, in what perspective is this novel written? Is it the author straight up telling you the characterization of each girl, or is it another girl's point of view? In other words, how is Lindsay giving you the characterization of these characters? Is she giving you dialogue from other characters? Is she giving you the missing girls' past actions? How did Lindsay suggest that something promiscuous has occurred? Is it hinted in her word choice, or is it the drama unfolding before you, that you as the reader must analyze to draw conclusions? This book sounds like a great read. I love books that really target the raw cores of human beings. They tell us those parts of ourselves that society (let's be honest here: we) just want to keep under wraps. What's funny is that these events, like the one in this novel, occur because we choose to hide such infamy, instead of questioning and discussing their unmistakable presence.
ReplyDelete